QUESTION

+1 vote
asked by
Metal sheet versus Antenova SMD: most robust solution for IoT?
We are building a new version of our IoT gateway,
previous version used a pcb trace antenna for 868MHz and external GSM antenna.
Our pcb is  82mm x 99mm, plastic housing.

For the new device we want all antenna's fixed to the pcb (no external antennae).
We were offered a metal sheet antenna for 868MHz that claims to offer
good RX/TX performance but is also very easy on external influences of where the system
is mounted (close to wall, vertical/horizontal).

Antenova claims to have a SMD solution that is robust (little influence of device surroundings),
but how does this compare to metal sheets (e.g. ProANT onboard 868 )
http://www.proant.se/en/catalog/embedded-antennas/--onboard-smd-antenna/onboard-smd-868915-antenna-pid55.htm

And what type Antenova would provide best performance: Velox ISM?

As for GSM, we have a LTE-M1 SIM7000E, what Antenova SMD antenna will offer
best perfomance?
Tri-Band (800,900,1800) FDD-LTE B3/B8/B20.
LTE-M1
LTE-NB1
GPRS/EDGE 900/1800Mhz (EGSM900, DCS1800)

Please log in or register to answer this question.

1 Answer

+2 votes
answered by
edited ago by
My favuritefor cellular is Lucida https://www.antenova.com/product/lucida-antenna-for-lte-cellular-and-mimo/
Your request is for band 3, 8 and 20. If this is enough, then Calvus is maybe nicer https://www.antenova.com/product/calvus-a10340h/
As less bands the antenna has to support as better is often the return loss. Just compare the two data sheets.

For 868 MHz you should use a 90 degree angle for the antenna to get a resonable antenna isolation. My recommendation is to develop 2 empty PCBs with antennas and battery in the final enclosure, to check return loss and to mesur the antenna isolation.

Meet the moderators

Geoff Schulteis

Senior Antenna Apps Specialist at Antenova Geoff is an antenna design-in and OTA measurement specialist. His knowledge of FCC and world carrier requirements is second-to-none.

Dan Dobransky

Senior Antenna Apps Specialist at Antenova Dan is an antenna integration specialist. With years of design-in experience, he helps Antenova's customers wireless designs thrive.

download-guide-image

Antennas: The Comparison Guide

Find the perfect antenna for your project

Download
...